Menus
Please call or order online through the online ordering link !!
all items subject to availability!
Buckets & Trays Take out only
Trays will feed 4 - 6 people-
Shrimp Bucket
16 fried shrimp, 2 coleslaw, and 2 fries
-
24 Piece Shrimp Bucket
24 hand breaded large fried shrimp, served with crispy fries, cocktail sauce and cole slaw
-
Chicken Finger Bucket
10 chicken tenders with fries served with honey mustard or bbq. sauce
-
25 Piece Chicken Tender Bucket
25 each jumbo chicken tenders. Served with french fries apple sauce honey mustard and BBQ sauce
-
1 Pound Fried Flounder
1 pound of hand breaded fried flounder served with tarter sauce. No sides
-
2.5 Pounds Fried Flounder
2.5 Pounds of hand breaded Fried Flounder, served with tarter sauce. No sides
-
Grilled Shrimp Skewers over Island Rice Tray
6 shrimp per skewers over island rice and served with pineapple teriyaki sauce on the side. Serves 6
-
Island Grill's famous Pulled Pork Tray
3 Pounds of in house smoked pulled pork served with Hawaiian Kings bread, butter and Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce Serves 6
-
Maple Pecan Salmon Tray
baked jail island salmon, crushed pecans, maple glaze. Serves 6
-
Grilled Chicken Parm Tray
8oz grilled chicken breast, marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese Serves 6
-
Island Rice Tray
-
Sautéed Mix Vegetables Tray
-
ColeSlaw lb.
-
Caesar Salad Tray
-
Garden Salad Tray
-
6 Baked Potato tray with butter & Sour Cream
Thanks for stopping by. We are currently offering Curbside, pick up, inside or outside dining. Please use our our online ordering to place your order .
Please note that due to many price fluctuations in the food market, and increase in daily operating expenses prices are subject to change
Appetizers
-
Cheese Bites
Fried Wisconsin Mozzarella cheese curds served with marinara
$10.85
-
Chicken Tenders
Jumbo chicken tenders lightly fried served with choice of honey mustard or BBQ sauce
$10.50
-
Onion Rings
Half pound of golden crispy beer battered onions rings with marinara
$8.50
-
Island Grill's Wam Bam Shrimp
crispy fried Land shark shrimp tossed in our wam bam sauced with scallions
$14.85
-
Baja Fish Tacos
Two flour tortillas filled with fresh fish, black beans, tomatoes, our homemade baja slaw, lettuce, and a side of fresh Pico de gallo
$11.50
-
Fried Calamari Rings
Crispy battered calamari rings deep fried and served with homemade marinara sauce
$15.85
-
Coconut Shrimp
4 jumbo fried sweet coconut shrimp serve with sweet n sour dip
$16
-
Island Wings
10 Lightly breaded and fried x-large wings, choice of mild, hot, garlic scampi, sweet chili bbq. Jamaican Jerk, or bbq. sauce
$14
Quesadillas
Add Sour cream .99 cents and or guacamole $2.50-
BBQ. Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled chicken breast diced then topped with a four blend cheese and our BBQ. sauce. Served with a side of homemade Pico de Gallo
$14
-
Philly Quesadilla
Tender chopped Philly steaks and sautéed onions with our four cheese blend. Served with a side of pico-de-gallo
$15
-
Quesadilla in Paradise
This bacon cheeseburger quesadilla is a new twist. Our fresh burger chopped with bacon, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, and our four cheese blend in a crispy flour tortilla.
$15
-
Crab Quesadilla Grande
Filled tortilla with crabmeat, onions, tomatoes, blend of cheeses, and pico de Gallo on the side
$26
-
Chicken Quesadilla
grilled chicken breast, four blend cheese, pico de gallo
$13
-
Plain Quesadilla
one stuffed tortilla with our four cheese blend. Includes side of Pico de Gallo
$8
-
Pulled Pork Quesadilla
Our own in house smoked pulled pork, shredded then stuffed into a BBQ and cheese quesadilla with a side of Pico de Gallo
$13
Soups
-
New England Clam Chowder (white)
small 8 oz
medium 16 oz
large 32 oz
-
Shrimp & Corn Chowder
small 8 oz
medium 16 oz
large 32 oz
-
Lobster Bisque
small 8 oz
medium 16 oz
large 32 oz
-
Conch Chowder
per 8 oz
per 16 oz
per 32 oz
Salads
-
Jamaican me Crazy Salad
Grilled all natural Jamaican Jerk Seasoned chicken over a garden salad with mango chunks, strawberries and black beans. Served with a side of Caribbean Mango vinaigrette
$18
-
Buffalo Chicken Tender Salad
Sliced buffalo chicken tenders served on a garden salad in a tortilla shell served with your choice of dressing
$13.50
-
Build Your Own Caesar
Your choice of protein over a bed of romaine lettuce served with a creamy Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread. Or choose a garden salad with your choice of dressing on the side
Grilled Chicken $14
Grilled Shrimp $18
Grilled Salmon $19
Blacken Ahi Tuna $19
-
Caesar Salad
Small $5
Large $8.50
-
Garden Salad
Small $4.50
Large $7.50
-
Salad Dressings
Raspberry Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Blue Cheese, 1000 Island, Honey Mustard, Caribbean Mango Vinaigrette
Sandwiches
-
Jersey Shore flounder Reuben
Lightly fried flounder served with Baja Slaw, Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island on grilled marble rye bread. Served with French fries
$18.50
-
Philly Cheese Steak
Original style Philly chopped steak served with American cheese on a torpedo roll. Served with crispy fries and slaw
$14
-
Mahi Reuben
Pan seared mahi mahi, Baja slaw, Swiss cheese, thousand island dressing, grilled marble rye bread
$19
-
Pulled Pork Sandwich
A generous portion of in house smoked pulled pork topped with Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce. Served on a gourmet bun with crispy fries and slaw
$13.85
-
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Char-grilled chicken breast with buffalo sauce served on a gourmet roll and a side of bleu cheese
$13
-
Crab Cake Sandwich
One pan seared crab cake served on a gourmet bun with lettuce and tomato and choice of tartar or cocktail sauce
$25
-
Summer Chicken Sandwich
grilled all-natural chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, Swiss cheese, sautéed onions, garlic aioli, brioche bun, fries, coleslaw
$13.50
Bangin' Burgers
Burgers are served on a gourmet bun with lettuce, tomato, pickles and fries. Additional toppings $1 each. Choice of cheese, fried onions, fried mushrooms, haystack onions or BBQ sauce Add bacon $2. Add cole slaw for $1.00-
6 oz Certified Angus Burger
6 oz CAB burger served on a Brioche bun with Island Grill fries Includes two toppings. Served with crispy fries.
$10.50
-
Double Bacon Cheese Burger
Includes your choice of cheese and 4 strips of juicy bacon layered between two 6 oz certified Angus beef patties. Served with crispy fries
$16.75
-
California Veggie Burger
Doc Praeger veggie pattie served with lettuce, tomato, on a gourmet bun. Served with French fries
$11
-
Cowboy Burger
Twin 6oz burger topped with Haystack onions, BBQ sauce and Cheddar cheese. Served with crispy fries
$16.75
-
OC Burger
6 oz CAB burger topped with Swiss cheese, our haystack onions and garlic aioli. Served with crispy fries.
$13
Seafood Combos
Include choice of a garden or Caesar salad and one side dish-
Grilled Shrimp & Chicken
6 Grilled shrimp with a grilled chicken breast
$21
-
Broiled Shrimp, Lobster and Scallops
6 shrimp, one 4 oz lobster tail and sea scallops
$39
-
Mini Combo
Fresh local Cape May scallops with jumbo shrimp and flounder broiled in our white wine, butter, and lemon juice mixture.
$35
-
Shrimp & Lobster Combo
6 broiled shrimp with a 4oz cold water lobster tail
$29
-
Seafood Supreme
A great sampling of the sea, Cape May Scallops, Crab cake Stuffed shrimp, and flounder.
$42
-
Shrimp & Crab Cake
6 grilled shrimp with one Island Grill sautéed crab cake
$31
-
Shrimp & Filet
6 grilled shrimp with one 8 oz grilled Filet Mignon
$43
-
Shrimp & Flounder
6 broiled shrimp with fresh broiled flounder
$24
-
Ultimate Combo
Twin 4 oz cold water lobster tails, four jumbo stuffed shrimp with crab imperial, 4 large day boat scallops, flounder
$79
Island Grill Tacos
Taco platters include choice of salad and sauteed mixed vegetablesFried Seafood
Fried platters include choice of a garden or Caesar salad French fries and cole slaw-
Fried Scallops
Local Day Boat Jersey scallops lightly breaded then fried to perfection, served with your choice of sauce
$34
-
Captain's Platter
large sautéed crab cake, fried flounder, 4 fried jumbo shrimp, 4 fried local day boat scallops
$39
-
Fish & Chips
LandShark beer battered then panko breaded and deep fried and served over french fries and a side of homemade cole slaw
$24
-
Coconut Shrimp
6 jumbo hand dipped coconut shrimp, sweet n sour sauce
$28
-
Chicken Tender Basket
Large chicken tenders served French fries and Cole slaw with BBQ sauce or honey mustard
$16.95
-
Fried Flounder
Fresh flounder, hand-breaded and fried to perfection.
$21
-
Large Fried Shrimp
8 hand breaded shrimp served with choice of cocktail or tartar sauce
$24
-
Fried Shrimp & Cod `
5 Fried shrimp and a filet of breaded cod, fries and slaw
$23
Vegetarian
From the Grill
Includes choice of garden or Caesar salad-
Filet Mignon
8 oz Tender cut USDA Prime Filet Mignon. Choice of one side dish
$37
-
Cedar Plank Salmon
Oven baked salmon on a charred cedar plank served with a spicy orange sauce on the side
$28
-
Baby Back Ribs Full Rack
Over two and a half pounds of our own smoked Baby Back Ribs with dry rub or our own BBQ sauce Half Rack 25 (1.5lbs)
$35
-
Double Grilled Chicken Breast
Two all-natural grilled chicken breasts served with your choice of seasoning.
$21
-
Honey Garlic Chicken
Grilled chicken with a honey garlic glaze on a bed of island rice and broccoli.
$17.50
-
Surf n Turf
USDA choice fillet mignon, broiled 4 oz cold water lobster tail, drawn butter. Twin tails $63
$51
-
12 oz Carrot NY Strip Steak
12 oz NY strip cut of grass fed beef finished with carrots(eaten by the cows) for a less earthy flavor.
$34
Kitchen Specialties
Specialties include choice of garden or Caesar salad. No substitutions please!! Plus one side dish unless otherwise noted-
Island Drunken Shrimp
Eight jumbo shrimp, pan seared and topped with a Golden Butter Rum Sauce. Served over a bed of Island Grill rice with roasted corn. (no sides)
$23
-
Black & White Ahi Tuna
Pan-seared 10 oz Ahi Tuna with Black and White Sesame Seeds. Chef recommended medium-rare.
$26
-
Alaskan King Crab Legs
1½ pound of jumbo sweet tender Alaskan Crab Legs served with warm drawn butter. (subject to availability)
$85
-
Baja Fish Tacos
Four Flour tortillas filled with fresh mahi , lettuce, tomatoes, black beans and Baja Slaw. Includes a side of Pico de Gallo
$21
-
Maple Pecan Salmon
Pecan crusted Jail Island Salmon, baked with a maple glaze
$27
-
Lemon Garlic Scallops
Pan seared local day boat scallops atop a lemon beurre blanc sauce with a hint of garlic
$34
-
Broiled Crab Imperial
Our homemade broiled jumbo lump crab imperial.
$38.50
A la Carte
-
French Fries
-
Apple Sauce, Cole Slaw, or Oranges
-
Baked Potato
-
Potato of the Day
-
Guacamole
-
Pico de Gallo
-
Island Rice
-
Sour Cream
-
Sautéed Mixed Vegetables
Bottled Beverages
See online ordering app for a complete list of available beverages-
Pepsi 20 oz plastic bottle
Pepsi,Pepsi Zero, Mountain Dew, Mountain Dew Zero, Mug Root Beer, Orange Crush, Sierra Mist
-
San Pellegrino Plastic bottle 16.9 oz
-
Monster energy drink and Monster zero sugar
Dessert
-
Island Grill Homemade Key Lime Pie
$5
-
Tuxedo Bomb
$7
Kids items include choice of french fries, apple sauce or mandarin oranges.
Choice of kids juice box!!
12 and under only, please!
Download PDFFavorites
-
Kids Cheese Quesadilla
-
Kids Chicken Tenders
-
Kids Grilled Cheese
-
Kids Hot Dog
-
Kids Jumbo Burger
-
Kids Fried Flounder
-
Kids Fried Shrimp
Healthier Options
-
Kids Grilled Shrimp
-
Kids Baked Salmon
-
Kids 4 oz Grilled Chicken Breast