Menus

Corkscrew Calamari

Crispy battered calamari deep fried and served with homemade Garlic Aioli and Marinara sauce

$12.50

Austin's Chicken Tenders

Fresh Holly chicken tenders hand breaded in house and lightly fried served with Mikes Hot Honey

$9.50

Island Grill's Famous Wam Bam Shrimp

Deep fried LandShark battered shrimp tossed in our own Wam Bam Sauce, topped with fresh scallions

$12.50

Cheese Bites

Fried Wisconsin Mozzarella cheese curds served with marinara

$9.50

Baja Fish Tacos

Two flour tortillas filled with fresh fish, black beans, tomatoes, our homemade baja slaw, lettuce, and a side of fresh Pico de gallo

$8.50

Onion Rings

Half pound of golden crispy beer battered onions rings with marinara

$6.50

Boneless Wings

Fresh tender boneless chicken thighs lightly dusted and fried golden brown and tossed with you favorite sauce. Choice of mild buffalo, hot, Sweet Chili, garlic scampi parm or Barbecue

$10

New England Clam Chowder (white)

Cup $4

Bowl $6

Lobster Bisque

Cup $5

Bowl $7

Shrimp & Corn Chowder

Cup $4

Bowl $6

Soup Sampler

Eat in only. New England Clam, Shrimp & Corn, and Lobster Bisque

$7

Jamaican me Crazy Salad

Grilled all natural Jamaican Jerk Seasoned chicken over a garden salad with mango chunks, strawberries and black beans. Served with a side of your choice of dressing

$14

Wam Bam Salad

Our own Wam Bam Shrimp over a garden salad with Mandarin Oranges, Candied nuts, Craisins, and Scallions in a Tortilla Bowl. Served with your choice of dressing

$15

Build Your Own Caesar

Your choice of protein over a bed of romaine lettuce tossed with a creamy Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread

Grilled Chicken Caesar $12

Grilled Salmon Caesar $16

Grilled Shrimp Caesar $16

Quesadilla in Paradise

This bacon cheeseburger quesadilla is a new twist. Our fresh burger chopped with bacon, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, and our four cheese blend in a crispy flour tortilla

$13.50

Crab Quesadilla Grande

Large tortilla stuffed with onions, tomatoes, crabmeat, and a blend of cheeses. Served with a side of fresh Pico de Gallo

$16

BBQ. Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled chicken breast diced then topped with a four blend cheese and our BBQ. sauce. Served with a side of homemade Pico de Gallo

$12.50

Vegetable Quesadilla

One over stuffed tortilla with Spinach, tomatoes, onions, black beans and our four cheese cheddar blend. Served with a side of Pico de Gallo

$9

Philly Quesadilla

Tender chopped Philly steaks and sautéed onions with our four cheese blend. Served with a side of pico-de-gallo

$12

Jersey Shore flounder Reuben

Lightly fried flounder served with Baja Slaw, Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island on grilled marble rye bread. Served with French fries

Mahi Reuben

Pan seared Mahi Mahi served with Baja Slaw, Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island on grilled marble rye bread. Served with crispy fries

$16

Crab Melt

Open face sandwich on rye bread with crab imperial sliced tomatoes and Swiss cheese. Served with fries and slaw

$17

Patty Melt

One 6 oz burger with Swiss cheese, and sautéed onions between grilled marble rye

$8

Belly Buster Fish Sandwich

Large Breaded fish filet served on a torpedo roll with lettuce and tomato, topped with Baja Slaw and served with French fries

$14

B.L.T. Club

$8

Philly Cheese Steak

The Original Philly Cheese Steak

$11

Island Chicken Sandwich

Grilled Chicken breast topped with mushrooms, buffalo sauce, Swiss cheese, and bacon. Served with fries and slaw

$13

California Chicken Sandwich

Grilled all natural 8 oz chicken breast, topped with Guacamole, Swiss cheese, bacon, haystack onions, lettuce and tomato. Served with fries and slaw

$14

Fish & Chips Platter

Hand breaded jumbo fillets deep fried and served over french fries and a side of homemade cole slaw

$15

Broiled Tilapia Platter

Fresh Blue Tilapia broiled to perfection and served with baked potato and sautéed vegetables

$14

Grilled Salmon Platter

Grilled fresh salmon served with sautéed vegetables and Baked potato

$16

Crab Cake Platter

One large crab cake served with fries and cole slaw choice of tartar or cocktail sauce

$16

Double Bacon Cheese Burger

Includes your choice of cheese and 4 strips of juicy bacon layered between two 6 oz certified Angus Beef patties

$14

6 oz Certified Angus Burger

6 oz CAB burger served on a Brioche bun with Island Grill fries Includes two toppings

$9

Cowboy Burger

Twin 6oz burger topped with Haystack onions, BBQ sauce and Cheddar cheese

$14

Vegetable Burger (California)

One California style veggie patty, with lettuce, tomato, and sliced pickle on a Brioche bun. Includes french fries and slaw

$8

Impossible Burger

4 oz seared meatless plant based patty. Yes it's vegetarian. Served on a Gluten free ancient grain bun with micro greens, sliced tomato, french fries and cole slaw

$14

Cheese Bites

Fried Wisconsin Mozzarella cheese curds served with marinara

$9.50

Corkscrew Calamari

Crispy battered calamari deep fried and served with homemade Garlic Aioli and Marinara sauce

$13

Island Grill's Famous Wam Bam Shrimp

Deep fried LandShark battered shrimp tossed in our own Wam Bam Sauce, topped with fresh scallions

$13

Austin's Chicken Tenders

Fresh Holly chicken tenders hand breaded in house and lightly fried served with Mikes Hot Honey

$9.50

Coconut Shrimp

4 Golden fried Jumbo hand breaded coconut shrimp, served with a side of Sweet n Sour sauce

$14

Onion Rings

Half pound of golden crispy beer battered onions rings with marinara

$6.50

Baja Fish Tacos

Two flour tortillas filled with fresh fish, black beans, tomatoes, our homemade baja slaw, lettuce, and a side of fresh Pico de gallo

$9

Island Grill's Jumbo Wings

Oven-roasted extra-large wings served with your choice of seasoning. Mild sauce, BBQ sauce, Sweet Chili BBQ sauce, Old Bay, or Cajun

$13

Boneless Chicken Wings

Lightly breaded boneless chicken wings. fried then tossed with your choice of sauce Mild, Hot, Garlic Scampi, Sweet Chili BBQ or BBQ Sauce. Includes blue cheese or ranch dressing and celery

$10.50

Chicken Skewers with Pita Wedges

Oven-Baked chicken skewers served with warm Pita Wedges

$12

Crab Quesadilla Grande

Large tortilla stuffed with onions, tomatoes, crabmeat, and a blend of cheeses. Served with a side of fresh Pico de Gallo

$18

BBQ. Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled chicken breast diced then topped with a four blend cheese and our BBQ. sauce. Served with a side of homemade Pico de Gallo

$13

Philly Quesadilla

Tender chopped Philly steaks and sautéed onions with our four cheese blend. Served with a side of pico-de-gallo

$12

Quesadilla in Paradise

This bacon cheeseburger quesadilla is a new twist. Our fresh burger chopped with bacon, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, and our four cheese blend in a crispy flour tortilla.

$13.50

New England Clam Chowder (white)

Cup $4

Bowl $6

Shrimp & Corn Chowder

Cup $4

Bowl $6

Lobster Bisque

Cup $5

Bowl $7

Soup Sampler

Eat in only. New England Clam, Shrimp & Corn, and Lobster Bisque

$7

Jamaican me Crazy Salad

Grilled all natural Jamaican Jerk Seasoned chicken over a garden salad with mango chunks, strawberries and black beans. Served with a side of your choice of dressing

$15.50

Crab Salad

Jumbo lump crabmeat in our own creamy mixture, served over a bed of fresh crisp lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers and green peppers served in a large tortilla shell

$19

Wam Bam Salad

Our own Wam Bam Shrimp over a garden salad with Mandarin Oranges, Candied nuts, Craisins, and Scallions in a Tortilla Bowl. Served with your choice of dressing

$16.50

Buffalo Chicken Tender Salad

Sliced buffalo chicken tenders served on a garden salad in a tortilla shell served with your choice of dressing

$11

Build Your Own Caesar

Your choice of protein over a bed of romaine lettuce tossed with a creamy Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread

Grilled Chicken Caesar $12

Grilled Shrimp Caesar $17

Grilled Salmon Caesar $18

Caesar Salad

Small $4

Large $7

Garden Salad

Small $3.50

Large $6

Salad Dressings

Raspberry Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Parmesan Peppercorn Ranch, Blue Cheese, 1000 Island, Honey Mustard

Crab Melt

Open face sandwich on rye bread with crab imperial sliced tomatoes and Swiss cheese. Served with fries and slaw

$19

Mahi Reuben

Pan seared Mahi Mahi served with Baja Slaw, Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island on grilled marble rye bread. Served with crispy fries

$16

Jersey Shore flounder Reuben

Lightly fried flounder served with Baja Slaw, Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island on grilled marble rye bread. Served with French fries

$17

Grilled Summer Chicken Sandwich

Fresh all-natural grilled chicken breast served on a Brioche bun. Topped with Garlic Aioli sauce and sauteed onions. Served with lettuce & tomato french fries and coleslaw

$11

Philly Cheese Steak

Original style Philly chopped steak served with American cheese on a torpedo roll

$10

Lobster Reuben

Succulent baked cold water lobster tail served with Baja slaw, Swiss Cheese, and 1000 Island on grilled marble rye. Served with crispy fries

$21

Mushroom Swiss Burger

6 oz CAB Beef burger topped with sautéed mushrooms and Swiss cheese. Served with crispy fries.

$9.75

6 oz Certified Angus Burger

6 oz CAB burger served on a Brioche bun with Island Grill fries Includes two toppings. Served with crispy fries.

$9.75

Double Bacon Cheese Burger

Includes your choice of cheese and 4 strips of juicy bacon layered between two 6 oz certified Angus beef patties. Served with crispy fries

$14.75

OC Burger

6 oz CAB burger topped with Swiss cheese, our haystack onions and garlic aioli. Served with crispy fries.

$12

Cowboy Burger

Twin 6oz burger topped with Haystack onions, BBQ sauce and Cheddar cheese. Served with crispy fries

$14.75

Island Grill's Crab Cakes

One or two homemade lightly sautéed crab cakes, a local favorite served with fresh vegetables and Parmesan herb potatoes

One $19

Two $26

Crab Imperial

Our own creamy imperial mixture with jumbo lump crab meat, broiled to perfection. Served with parmesan herb potatoes and sautéed mixed vegetables

$26

Shrimp & Lobster Combo

A sea lovers delight with six jumbo broiled shrimp and our 4 oz cold water lobster tail served with drawn butter. Served with fresh vegetables and parmesan herb potatoes

$29

Maple Pecan Salmon

Oven baked Salmon dusted with crushed pecans and a light maple glaze. Served with baked potato and Edamame Corn salad

$25

Mini Combo

Fresh local Cape May scallops with jumbo shrimp and flounder broiled in our white wine, butter and lemon juice mixture. Served with sautéed mixed vegetables and parmesan herb potatoes

$28

Seafood Supreme

A great sampling of the sea, Cape May Scallops, Crab Stuffed shrimp, and flounder. Served with parmesan herb potatoes and sautéed mixed vegetables

$32

Ultimate Combo

The perfect combo. Two 4 oz cold water lobster tails, Three jumbo stuffed shrimp with crab, local Cape May Scallops and flounder. Served with sautéed mixed vegetables and parmesan herb potatoes

$45

Crabcake and Lobster Combo

One jumbo sauteed crabcake served with one cold water lobster tail. Served with drawn butter, Sauteed vegetables and potato of the day

$30

Baja Fish Tacos

Four flour tortillas filled with fresh fish, black beans, tomatoes, homemade Baja slaw, and lettuce with a side of fresh Pico de gallo and Edamame corn salad

$19

Captain's Platter

A hearty combination including one sautéed crab cake, fried flounder, fried jumbo shrimp and fried Cape May scallops.

$29

Fried Coconut Shrimp

6 jumbo hand dipped coconut shrimp served with sweet n sour sauce.

$25.50

Fried Scallops

Local Day Boat Jersey scallops lightly breaded then fried to perfection, served with your choice of sauce

$25

Large Fried Shrimp

8 jumbo hand breaded fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce

$22

Fish & Chips

LandShark beer battered then panko breaded and deep fried and served over french fries and a side of homemade cole slaw

$19

Chicken Tender Basket

One pound of hand breaded chicken tenders, served with BBQ sauce or honey mustard

$14.75

Fried Flounder

Fresh flounder, hand-breaded and fried to perfection.

$19

Vegetable Burger (California)

One California style veggie patty, with lettuce, tomato, and sliced pickle on a Brioche bun. Includes french fries and slaw

$8

Vegetable Quesadilla

One over stuffed tortilla with Spinach, tomatoes, onions, and black beans with our four cheese cheddar blend. Includes salad. No Sides

$11

Island Drunken Shrimp

Eight jumbo shrimp, pan seared and topped with a Golden Butter Rum Sauce. Served over a bed of Island Grill rice with roasted corn. (no sides)

$22

Shrimp & Grits

Jumbo shrimp sautéed with onions, peppers, and Andouille sausage in a light cream sauce over cheesy grits (no sides)

$19

Black & White Ahi Tuna

Pan seared 10 oz Ahi Tuna with Black and White Sesame Seeds. Chef recommended medium rare. Served with a side of Japanese dipping sauce and Parmesan herb potatoes and Sautéed mixed vegetables

$23

Scallops with a Lemon Cream Sauce

Fresh local pan seared Cape May Scallops, served over a Lemon Cream Buerre Blanc sauce. Served with parmesan herb potatoes and sautéed mixed vegetables

$29

Cedar Plank Salmon

Fresh salmon seasoned, grilled and served on a cedar plank with a side spicy orange sauce and Parmesan herb potatoes and sautéed mixed vegetables

$27

French Fries

$3

Apple Sauce, Cole Slaw, or Oranges

$0.99

Baked Potato

$2.50

Potato of the Day

$1.99

Guacamole

$2.50

Pico de Gallo

$1

Island Rice

$2.75

Sour Cream

$0.75

Sautéed Mixed Vegetables

$1.99

Filet Mignon

8 oz Tender cut USDA Prime Filet Mignon. Includes baked potato and sautéed mixed vegetables

$30

Single Surf n Turf

8 oz Filet Mignon with one broiled 4 oz cold water lobster tail. Served with drawn butter. Served with Parmesan herb potatoes and sautéed mixed vegetables

$43

Double tails (new size) $53

Honey Garlic Chicken

Grilled chicken breast topped with our honey garlic glaze and served over a bed of island rice and broccoli.

$16

Grilled Chicken with Mango

Lightly grilled BBQ chicken breast topped with our fresh mango salsa. Served with roasted corn with Poblano peppers and Baja coleslaw

$18

Double Grilled Chicken Breast

Two all natural grilled chicken breasts, served with your choice of seasoning. Includes mashed potatoes and Edamame corn salad

$18

Land & Sea Combo

8 oz tender Filet mignon served with one sauteed crabcake. Includes potato and vegetable of the day

$37

Fountain Beverages

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Ginger Ale, Sierra Mist, Birch Beer, Wild Cherry Pepsi, Lemonade, and fruit punch (free refills)

$2.85

Fresh Brewed Unsweetened Iced Tea (free refills)

$2.85

Assorted Juices

V-8, Apple, Ruby Red, Orange Juice, Cranberry

9 oz $1.65

16 oz $2.99

Lavazza Coffee Endless Cup

$2.75

Hot Tea

$1.75

San Pellegrino Glass

$2.35

Fiji Water

Bottled

$2

Smart Water

$2.50